The central fallacy of public schooling

Foundation for Economic Education
Posted: August 21st, 2008 by Thomas L. Knapp
Author: Daniel Hager

“Indoctrination itself is not illegitimate. In fact, it is an intrinsic part of child rearing. Out of love and concern, parents explicitly or implicitly formulate desired outcomes for the young lives they have created. Parents generally hope their children will adhere to their own traditions and belief systems, which they attempt to inculcate. The question parents must face is, ‘Who will do the indoctrinating?’ Schooling is an adjunct to child rearing. The schooling options available force parents to make decisions regarding the level of autonomy they wish to exercise. They retain the greatest control over their children’s developing beliefs by schooling them at home. An alternative is to enroll their children in an institution where they are certain the indoctrination conforms to their own values, such as a religious school. When parents send a child to a tax-funded school, they sacrifice their autonomy to alien interests.” (originally published 1999; posted 08/20/08)

Leave a Reply